The Stopwatch Gardener

A gardening blog from Sheila M. Averbuch

A good death for roses


Click for larger imageOne consolation of November is the opportunity to look at the bare root roses which become available now. Our garden already hosts an embarrassingly large number of roses wherever there’s reliable sun, and many are true survivors, offering perfect flowers through November. As I mentioned previously, these sumptuous blooms look a bit wrong in the declining autumn garden, but I’ve solved the problem by using them as a cutting patch from October onwards. These last weeks Rosa Tess of the d’Urbervilles and R. James Galway have sat merrily on my desk and in the kitchen, alongside the last of the dahlias and spice-scented pinks.

If you are planning next year’s roses, one aspect worth considering — but which marketing materials rarely describe — is how the flowers fade and die. If you want to cut roses for the house, they will start fading the moment secateurs meet stem, so it’s worth knowing which roses age gracefully and ultimately enjoy a good death. All these have earned their place in my garden but vary in their end-of-life beauty:

  • Rosa James Galway: a nearly thornless climber from David Austin which for me has only the slightest scent in the garden. But in the vase, James Galway absolutely shines. It begins to give off a pleasant, old-Rose-meets-talcum-powder scent. Its baby-girl pink tones also fade to lavender, reminiscent of antique wallpaper. Best of all, even the smallest buds open, extending the vase life.
  • Jude the Obscure: also from David Austin, JtO has full, heavy heads of pale yellow-pink petals with an exquisitely fruity scent. They look a bit ponderous in the vase, but a single flower perfumed my office for days. The final petals actually gave off a final, perfect spritz of scent as they fell to the desk — amazing.
  • William Shakespeare 2000: I contacted David Austin to see if my experience of this rose was typical, and it seems it is. What a beauty this rose is in the garden — strongly fragrant, packed with red petals. But look away when it starts to fade. The petals tend to turn brown and cling on instead of falling peacefully one by one, so entire heads can rot on the stem. The vase life in my experience is not good.
  • Tess of the d’Urbervilles: a strong climbing red also from David Austin, with such lust for life that it happily endured six months shaded by scaffolding here. The flowers are perfection in the early stages and the vase life is excellent. But to me the scent is not very pleasant, and the petals eventually reflex back to an almost-puffball shape. But great for a mixed vase where other roses provide the scent.
  • Etoile de Holland: bred more than 70 years ago, EdH is famed as one of the best climbing reds. To me its scent is outrageously wonderful — a powerful, almost lemony aroma that, like Jude the Obscure, makes you want to eat the rose. The stems are short and the heads large, so arrangements need support. I put a dozen into a short, square vase topped with a plastic grid, and that worked. The flower form quickly declines from the stereotypical florist’s rosebud shape to a blown-open saucer, but together in a vase the scent of these roses is unbeatable.

Intensity and attractiveness of scent are subjective — one person’s wonderful is another person’s mediocre – but it’s easier to agree whether a fading rose is objectively beautiful or better off dead. Ask the growers you’re buying from this year what becomes of the flowers in the later stages, and inquire whether they have pictures to share. You’ll spend the next half-year looking forward to them, so it’s good to know what’s in store.

6 Comments to

“A good death for roses”

  1. On November 13th, 2009 at 11:38 pm Deborah at Kilbourne Grove Says:

    It is great to know if a rose “dies” attractively, before you invest the time and money in it. There is always so much to do in the garden, deadheading rotting, brown roses, is not one task that I would wish to take on.

  2. On November 17th, 2009 at 9:11 am Autumn Belle Says:

    That’s a beautiful rose and this is a beautiful post. I have dedicated my latest post “The Yellow Cassia Tress of KLCC Park” to you. Hope you like it. Thank you very much for being the first commenter of my ” Erythrina Glauca – The Red Flower Tree” post.

  3. On November 19th, 2009 at 1:04 am The Redneck Rosarian Says:

    Great post. So true, some roses die better than others. Our Veteran’s Honor and Gold Medal roses have long lasting blooms.

  4. On November 19th, 2009 at 9:10 am The StopWatch Gardener Says:

    Autumn Belle — thank you so much & I thoroughly enjoyed your post and detailed photos of Erythrina Glauca.

    Redneck Rosarian — what a great identity you’ve chosen, I love it! Must look into those two flowers you mention…are they scented?

  5. On November 19th, 2009 at 1:43 pm The Redneck Rosarian Says:

    Gold Medal has a nice fragrance
    Veteran’s Honor has no fragrance.

    My preference is a scented rose, but with modern hybrids they sacrifice fragrance for beauty….. a shame really….I now look for roses that give me both…..

  6. On November 20th, 2009 at 9:38 pm uberVU - social comments Says:

    Social comments and analytics for this post…

    This post was mentioned on Twitter by stopwatchgarden: Planning more #roses for your garden? It’s worth finding which ones fade gracefully and enjoy a “good death” #gardening…

Email will not be published

Website example

Your Comment: